"Unarmed and
Dangerous"
A Sermon preached by the Rev.
Deana Dudley
at
Christos Metropolitan
Community Church, Toronto, Ontario
and Holy Fellowship Metropolitan
Community Church, London, Ontario
July 20, 2003
King Herod heard of Jesus? miracles, and Jesus' name had
become known. Some were saying, "John the baptizer has been
raised from the dead; and for this reason these powers are at
work in him." But others said, "It is Elijah." And others
said, "It is a prophet, like one of the prophets of old." But
when Herod heard of it, he said, "John, whom I beheaded, has
been raised." For Herod himself had sent men who arrested
John, bound him, and put him in prison on account of Herodias,
his brother Philip's wife, because Herod had married her. For
John had been telling Herod, "It is not lawful for you to have
your brother's wife." And Herodias had a grudge against him,
and wanted to kill him. But she could not, for Herod feared
John, knowing that he was a righteous and holy man, and he
protected him. When he heard him, he was greatly perplexed;
and yet he liked to listen to him. But an opportunity came
when Herod on his birthday gave a banquet for his courtiers
and officers and for the leaders of Galilee. When his daughter
Herodias came in and danced, she pleased Herod and his guests;
and the king said to the girl, "Ask me for whatever you wish,
and I will give it." And he solemnly swore to her, "Whatever
you ask me, I will give you, even half of my kingdom." She
went out and said to her mother, "What should I ask for?" She
replied, "The head of John the baptizer." Immediately she
rushed back to the king and requested, "I want you to give me
at once the head of John the Baptist on a platter." The king
was deeply grieved; yet out of regard for his oaths and for
the guests, he did not want to refuse her. Immediately the
king sent a soldier of the guard with orders to bring John's
head. He went and beheaded him in the prison, brought his head
on a platter, and gave it to the girl. Then the girl gave it
to her mother. When his disciples heard about it, they came
and took his body, and laid it in a tomb. Mark
6:14-29
Well, now THAT?s a sordid little tale, isn?t it? A little
palace intrigue, a little dirty dancing, a little murder. And
they say reading the Bible?s good for your character.
And in spite of its sordidness ? or perhaps because of it ?
today?s gospel lesson has been told and retold, in plays and
ballets and operas and movies. Those of you who watched our
"Jesus of Nazareth" film fest last Lent may remember this
scene vividly. Actually, they showed the dancing, but kind of
finessed the beheading, which was fine with me.
How did John come to get his head on a platter? Well,
basically, he wouldn?t shut up. And this is a story about the
dangers of telling the truth, of speaking truth to power. But
if that?s ALL this account was about, it wouldn?t be very good
news, would it? Because John kind of gets it in the neck.. So
in order for us to find good news, the good news of Jesus
Christ in this, it has to be about something more. And it
is.
This account comes with after Jesus has just finished
giving instructions to his disciples about how they are to
embody God's love in the world. And he told them to expect
opposition and trouble. It?s gonna come, he tells them, but
the only thing you need to take with you is the good news and
your faith. And then, Mark, as if to kind of "slam dunk" the
point about opposition, reminds us of this story of John the
Baptist; and he does it in a very deliberate way.
In the first place he does it by reminding us of King
Herod?s great fear. Now, you may ? or may not ? remember that
this is not Herod the Great, who ruled Israel around the time
of Jesus' birth. This is the son of Herod the Great, who was
called Herod Antipas to keep them straight, and he was a chip
off the old block, just as cruel and evil and just plain nuts
as his old man. And according to Mark?s gospel, Herod had a
serious political controversy with John the Baptist. John had
any number of reasons to be ticked off at Herod, but the one
that really got John's goat was Herod's marriage to Herodias,
who was actually Herod?s brother?s wife, and that just wasn?t
kosher.
Actually, the marital entanglements of this whole family of
Herods are incredible. They started with Herod the Great, who
married five different wives, and had children by all of them.
Then the children began to marry each other, and each other's
children! So there were cousins marrying, and, in the case of
this Herod, Herod Antipas, he married his niece, Herodias, who
had been the wife of his half-brother, Philip. And to further
complicate the story, there was another half-brother also
named Philip! So John wasn?t just CONFUSED by all this, as I
am, he was also incensed by it. John publicly accused the
couple of "living in sin" and that turned Herodias practically
purple with rage. And being considerably butcher than her
husband, Herodias basically forced Herod Antipas into tossing
John into the dungeon until she could figure out what to do
with him.
Well, apparently Herod feared John almost ? but not quite ?
as much as he feared his wife. He knew how popular John was
with the people and how dangerous it could be politically if
he just got rid of John. At least in prison he thought he
could keep an eye on John, as well as keep peace in his own
bedroom. But it wasn't just fear that motivated Herod. He was
fascinated by John and couldn't help sneaking out at night and
wandering down to the basement just so that he could hear John
ranting in his old, dark prison cell, with a kind of morbid
fascination.
You know how, sometimes, you don?t really want to see or
hear something, but you just can?t help yourself? You can?t
NOT watch. It was like this song I heard on the radio
yesterday. Somebody thought it would be a great idea to do a
kind of a jazz/hip-hop version of the song "How Do You Solve a
Problem Like Maria" from the movie The Sound of Music. And it
was, as you rightly imagine, unbelievably horrible. But I
couldn?t stop listening to it. I just HAD to hear it out, to
see if they could really do it. And I guess Herod was like
that with John. He just had to keep going on down to the
dungeon to hear him out. Maybe not really WANTING to hear him,
but listening, all the same. The portrait Mark paints is of a
man who is transfixed with the very thing he fears and
despises. "When he heard him," Mark says, "...he was greatly
perplexed, and yet he liked to listen to him."
Unfortunately this fascination was not enough to convince
him to change his life; and the day Herod decided to throw a
birthday party for himself to end all birthday bashes, he
unwittingly set in motion forces the consequences of which he
could never have foreseen. And this was a big bash, a banquet
bound to impress all of
Herod's political cronies and enemies and to offend the
religiously scrupulous. The climax was when Herodias'
daughter, or niece, whom we know as Salome, though the gospels
never name her, danced an incredibly lascivious dance, sort of
a dance of the seven veils, that was meant to arouse Herod and
make him vulnerable to suggestion.
So Herodias saw her chance. When Herod offered her anything
she wanted for her dance, Herodias got Salome to ask for the
head of John the Baptist on a platter. And caught up in the
moment like the dirty-old man that he was, Herod gave in to
both his lust and his pride by following through on his oath
to Salome. And that, as they say, was the end of John the
Baptist.
Or so everybody thought.
By the time Mark tells us this story, John?s been dead for
some time and Jesus has been actively preaching his own
message throughout Galilee. Although Herod apparently didn't
know Jesus, he knew that something equally as powerful as John
was stirring out there among the people, and it made him
nervous. Mark reports that "...when Herod heard of it, he
said, "John, whom I beheaded, has been raised."" And he was
afraid, very afraid. As well he might be. The ancient church
patriarch John Chrysostom said of Herod?s murder of John, "He
cut off his head, but he could not cut off the voice." So I
think Herod was right to be afraid.
See, the powerful, like Herod, may look like they have it
all together, they may look like they?re invincible, but they
don?t and they?re not. And the powerful and truly EVIL, like
Herod, are more vulnerable still. It?s a bit of a paradox. But
I think this story is in Mark?s gospel to remind us of the
delusions of the powerful. They have a delusion of power.
You think not? Case in point, a little closer in time. In
the early 1920s, Gandhi and India's National Congress Party
began moving more and more towards civil disobedience as a
chief political strategy in order to achieve independence from
British colonial rule. The British tried to repress that
movement, sometimes violently, and repeatedly jailed Gandhi.
But he never gave up his vision of a free and independent
India. And more to the point, he never gave up the vision of
achieving his goals without shedding one drop of British
blood; so he continued to walk his way back and forth across
the country preaching the gospel of non-violent resistance.
And as he did so, his reputation began to spread throughout
India, such that both Hindu and Muslim villagers would come
from great distances on foot, just to catch a glimpse of him.
Never before, it seemed, had any political or perhaps
religious leader, in his own lifetime stirred the masses to
their very depths throughout the country. The powers that be
had to sit up and take notice. They deeply resented and feared
what Gandhi was trying to do, but they also couldn?t help but
admire what he represented. Eventually, the British Governor
of Madras, who lost no love on Gandhi, was forced to declare
that British Home Rule was dealing with an entirely new
political phenomenon. Here?s what he wrote in a contemporary
account:
"Gandhi is here with the whole of his gang. [I love that:
"his gang"] It?s amazing what an influence this man is
getting. One of my assistants came from Calcutta with them in
the train and was tremendously impressed with the huge crowds
at every station.... Our position is becoming one of
extraordinary difficulty. There is no doubt that this Gandhi
has got a tremendous hold on the public imagination."
Yeah, I?d say his position had become one of extraordinary
difficulty. Because someone who gets a hold on the hearts and
minds of the people, that?s the kind of threat that the
powers, the tyrants of this world fear most. One of the things
that kept such moral and religious giants like Gandhi going in
the face of such overwhelming odds was the profound
conviction, not just that love would eventually conquer,
because it will, but that evil would, in the end, defeat
itself. "When I despair," Gandhi said, "I remember that
throughout history tyrants and dictators have always failed in
the end. Think of it. Always."
I?ve done some work with a group called Soulforce, which is
an interfaith movement committed to ending spiritual violence
perpetuated by religious policies and teachings, in other
words by the religious powers that be, against queer people.
And it gets its name, Soulforce, from one of the names that
Gandhi and Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. gave to the principles
of relentless nonviolent resistance. Both civil rights leaders
believed that we were created to do justice and that when we
take even one little step in that direction it renews our
spirit (releases our own "soul force") as it helps transform
our society. That relentless, nonviolent resistance creates
those shifts in power.
You know, I performed my very first legal wedding of a
lesbian couple last night. It felt really good. Really, really
good to be able not just to affirm God?s blessing of a
relationship, but to make it legal. When I got to the point at
the end, where I pronounce the couple legally married, and say
"by the power vested in me by the province of Ontario and the
laws of this land...." I choked up a little. Because I
realized that because of the relentless justice work of so
many people, there?s been a shift in power. A little shift
towards justice. And that kind of power shift STILL makes
people afraid.
So, in the end, this story about John, and Herod isn?t just
a tale to tip us off about what is likely to befall Jesus in
the end too. We know the end of the story. We know that the
powerful got him in the end, too. That?s often what happens to
anybody with the courage to speak truth to the powerful. We
know how the story ends. Truth keeps on speaking to power,
until power lashes out to destroy it. Power's attempts to
destroy truth are ultimately futile, but their brutality can
be spectacular. Just look at the cross. So Mark is writing to
people who legitimately wondered about the effectiveness of
such truth-telling. Who legitimately wondered whether
following Jesus and speaking the truth of love to loveless
power would ever make any difference in the end.
Mark says yes. Mark says yes because Mark knew, and we
know, that in the end they could kill Jesus, but they couldn?t
kill his message. Like John, you can cut off the head, but not
the voice. Mark says that even defenseless, disarmed,
de-capitated, dead men, like John the Baptist, will always
haunt the powerful of this world. And they do. Like Gandhi.
Like Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. And if we are true to our own
calling, like us, too. We need to keep on speaking truth to
power. Because, the good news is, in the end, it matters. In
the end, the power of evil overthrows itself. In the end, the
truth of love wins.
Resources gratefully acknowledged: Barry Robinson,
"Keeping the Faith in Babylon: A pastoral resource for
Christians in Exile;" Peter J. Blackburn, Home Hill Uniting
Church, "Living the Truth".